Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Meg Salter's avatar

I have trained in Requisite Org. met Jacques personally and interviewed hundreds of people for organizational design engagements. And I do understand the lack of uptake by organizations. The whole process can be done poorly, unethically, with an implicit “hammer from the top” or “I’m better than you” vibe. It takes at least stratum 4 people to do it well.

Mark Tilley's avatar

This was fascinating and enlightening, thank you.

"The serious democratic problem is that the decisions a modern democracy is being asked to make are Stratum 6 or 7 decisions ... The voting population is operating, in the aggregate, at Stratum 2 with a substantial Stratum 3 minority. The stratum mismatch between the decision and the decision-maker is the systemic condition the contemporary political order has not yet acknowledged."

I wonder what analysis can reconcile this to Helene Landemore's and others' work in "the wisdom of crowds" (to use the colloquial phrase) - the evidence that a sufficiently large body of random individuals given the time to deliberate amongst themselves can provide better decision making than a small group of supposed experts. This, of course, is the basis for sortition as an alternative to electoral democracy.

6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?